02/19/2025
An example of a letter of testimony:
TESTIMONY IN STRONG OPPOSITION TO HB1118
House Committee on Health & Education
Hawaiʻi State Legislature
Chairperson and Members of the Committee:
I am submitting this testimony in strong opposition to HB1118 , a bill that seeks to prohibit new non-medical exemptions for school-aged children’s immunization requirements. While protecting public health is important, this bill directly conflicts with a newly signed executive order by President Donald J. Trump, which prohibits federal funding for schools that mandate COVID-19 vaccinations. If this bill is passed in its current form, Hawaiʻi’s public education system risks losing critical federal funding at a time when we cannot afford such financial losses.
Conflict with Federal Policy
On February 14, 2025, President Trump signed an executive order explicitly denying federal funding to any school—public or private—that mandates vaccinations. The bill’s removal of non-medical exemptions implies that future mandates could be imposed without exemptions. If such mandates could cause Hawaiʻi’s Department of Education, public schools, and higher education institutions to be ineligible for federal education funding from agencies like the U.S. Department of Education and the Department of Health and Human Services.
Financial Consequences for Hawaiʻi’s Schools
Hawaiʻi’s public schools and universities rely heavily on federal funding for various programs, including special education, Title I funding for low-income students, and federal grants for infrastructure improvements. If HB1118 leads to a vaccine mandate with no exemptions, the state could lose millions of dollars in federal assistance, forcing schools to cut essential services. We cannot afford to risk this funding, especially given Hawaiʻi’s already limited state education budget.
Parental Rights and Religious Freedom
Beyond financial concerns, HB1118 also threatens parental rights by removing the ability of families to make informed medical decisions for their children. The bill completely eliminates religious exemptions for new students, despite the fact that religious freedom is a fundamental right protected under the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. If the federal government recognizes a parent's right to refuse vaccines for their child, the state of Hawaiʻi should not create laws that contradict federal policy and invite legal challenges.
Medical Decision-Making Should Be Left to Families and Physicians
The bill argues that “herd immunity” is a reason to enforce stricter vaccination laws. However, risks factors of such items COVID-19 has a low transmission risk among children, and most schools across the country have already abandoned mandates for this vaccine. Forcing vaccination through legislation, without allowing for non-medical exemptions, removes the ability of parents and licensed medical professionals to make the best health decisions for individual children.
Potential Legal Challenges
If HB1118 passes and effectively enforces a vaccination mandate, the Hawaiʻi State Legislature will likely face lawsuits on multiple fronts:
Violation of President Trump’s Executive Order – Federal funding restrictions would be challenged in court, leading to unnecessary legal battles.
Violation of the First Amendment – Religious freedom lawsuits could arise from parents denied exemptions.
Violation of Federal Education Laws – Federal protections for students under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and other provisions could conflict with state mandates.
Conclusion: Do Not Pass HB1118
In light of these concerns, I urge the committee to vote NO on HB1118 . Removing non-medical exemptions for vaccinations, especially without consideration of federal policies, could have devastating financial consequences for Hawaiʻi’s education system while infringing upon parental rights and religious freedoms. Hawaiʻi should not put itself in direct conflict with federal law, risk losing federal funding, and invite costly legal challenges.
Mahalo for your time and consideration. I respectfully urge you to oppose HB1118 in order to protect Hawaiʻi’s children, schools, and fundamental freedoms.